Amz Consultors logo Amz Consultors AutomationBook a free strategy call

Product · Reviews & ratings

Removing reviews through community guideline reporting

Find the low-star reviews that break Amazon's community guidelines (shipping, seller service, damage on arrival and other non-product topics), prioritize them with an AI prompt, report them through Amazon's channels, and track the results.

Updated Oct 24, 20262 min readWho: VAHow often: Monthly on priority ASINs

Which reviews qualify

Product reviews should be about the product. Reviews that mainly focus on other things can break Amazon's community guidelines and be removed:

  • Shipping, delivery speed or packaging
  • Missing, damaged or wrong items received
  • Seller customer service, communication, returns or refunds
  • Ordering, payment or account issues
  • Promotional content, conflicts of interest or other non-product content

Prioritize ASINs where it matters: high-revenue ASINs rated 4.0–4.2 or 3.7–4.1 (deal eligibility), and any ASIN near a star threshold after recent low-star reviews.

1–2. Collect and prioritize the reviews

  1. Collect the reviews

    On the product page, open all reviews, filter critical (and 1-star and 2-star), and load as many as possible. Export them to a CSV, for example with the Instant Data Scraper Chrome extension, or copy them into a sheet.

  2. Prioritize with an AI assistant

    Upload the file to Claude, ChatGPT or Gemini with the prompt below.

ExamplePrompt

I've uploaded a CSV of Amazon reviews. Find reviews that may break Amazon's Community Guidelines, which say reviews shouldn't mainly focus on sellers or seller service, ordering issues, returns or refunds, shipping packaging, condition or damage on arrival, shipping cost or speed, or other fulfillment experiences.

For each review give: Tier 1 = clear violation, Tier 2 = likely, Tier 3 = borderline, Tier 4 = legitimate product review; the issue category; one sentence of reasoning.

Prioritize 1-star, then 2-star, then 3-star; ignore 4 and 5 stars. Return a table (review ID, content, rating, tier, category, reason) sorted by priority.

3. Report them through Amazon's channels

  1. Brand Registry: Report a violation

    For brand owners: find the ASIN, select the review and explain which guideline it breaks.

    Seller Central›Brand Registry›Protect›Report a violation›Customer reviews

  2. The "Report" link on the review

    Every review has a Report link on the product page.

  3. Seller Support case

    For a group of reviews about fulfillment by Amazon, open a case listing the review links.

For each review give the ASIN, the review link, the relevant quote, and why it isn't about the product. Keep it short, neutral and factual, and write each report specifically for that review.

4–5. Log and learn

Log every report right away (date, ASIN, review link, category, status). Each week, review submitted, removed and denied, the removal rate, and which categories succeed most in your niche; focus on those.

  • Priority ASINs chosen
  • Critical reviews exported
  • Reviews tiered with the AI prompt
  • Tier 1–2 reviews reported through Brand Registry or the Report link
  • Results logged and reviewed weekly

Want this done for you?

We run advertising, listings and account health for Amazon, Walmart and eBay brands. Start with a free review of your account.