Amz Consultors logo Amz Consultors AutomationBook a free strategy call

Account General · Account health & compliance

"Used sold as new" complaints

Why customers report used items when you only ship new stock, and the steps that bring these notifications down.

Updated Oct 18, 20262 min readWho: Account managerHow often: When a notification arrives; returns review monthly

What's happening

A customer says the item they received looked used. Amazon counts this as a product condition complaint. A few are normal; a steady stream can lead to the ASIN being blocked and FBA stock being held while Amazon investigates.

When you only send new stock, the cause is almost always returns. A returned unit that is opened but looks undamaged can be graded as sellable at the fulfillment center, put back into your stock and shipped to the next customer as new.

Steps that reduce complaints

  1. Find the returned units that went back to stock

    Download the FBA customer returns report for the last 90 days and filter for units marked sellable.

    Seller Central›Reports›Fulfillment›Customer Returns

  2. Remove doubtful returned units

    For products where any sign of use matters (hygiene, cosmetics, electronics), create a removal order for returned units and inspect them yourself.

    Seller Central›Inventory›Manage FBA Inventory›Create removal order

  3. Make opening visible

    Add a tamper-evident seal or shrink wrap so an opened unit is obvious and gets graded as unsellable.

  4. Use Amazon barcodes

    Label units with your FNSKU (Amazon barcode) rather than the manufacturer barcode, so your stock is never mixed with other sellers' units of the same product.

  5. Answer each notification

    Reply with what you found and what you changed. Keep the answer specific: ASIN, units checked, packaging change, date.

  6. Lower the return rate

    Read the return reasons. Unclear sizing, missing parts or a listing that oversells are the usual causes; fix them at the source.

Check it worked

Count the complaints per ASIN each month in a simple table. Changes to packaging need a full stock cycle to reach customers, so judge the result over 2–4 months, not weeks.

ASINUnits soldReturnsUsed-as-new complaintsAction taken
B0EXAMPLE11,24062 (5.0%)6Seal added from September batch
B0EXAMPLE286017 (2.0%)0None needed

Want this done for you?

We run advertising, listings and account health for Amazon, Walmart and eBay brands. Start with a free review of your account.