Amz Consultors logo Amz Consultors AutomationBook a free strategy call

Relaunch · Relaunch playbook

Product comparison table: which product to relaunch

Compare each candidate product with its 7–10 direct competitors on value for money, reviews, rating, sales, search volume growth and margin, and pick the 1–2 with the best starting point.

Updated Oct 25, 20263 min readWho: Account ownerHow often: Before choosing relaunch products

Why compare

Compare your products against each other to find the one with the greatest potential, so you know where to put your attention, time and resources. The comparison is about the offer, reviews and market position: the stronger your offer versus direct competitors, the more likely a relaunch succeeds.

The offer has four parts
PartWhat
Price / value for moneyYour price against what you provide
Main imageQuality and appeal
Number of reviewsHow many reviews you have
RatingYour overall rating

The stronger you are on these against direct competitors, the more shoppers pick you, and the easier it is to reach and hold a high rank.

Fill in the table

  1. Download the table

    Product comparison table ↓: one tab per product (rename it to the product's main keyword) and a Total comparison tab.

  2. Pick the candidates

    Higher sales, more reviews, and higher margins (at least 33% gross margin before PPC). e.g. the 4 products with the highest net margin last month, or 4 products with 300+ reviews.

  3. List 7–10 direct competitors

    As similar to your product as possible.

  4. Value for money

    Price, number of units or size, and price per unit. e.g. a 4-pack for $10 is $2.50 a unit; a 5-pack for $11 is better value at $2.20.

  5. Reviews and rating

    Each competitor's review count and star rating (e.g. 4.5 vs 4).

  6. Sales in the last 30 days

    From Jungle Scout or Helium 10, for each competitor and for you: your position among the top 10, and how much room you have to grow.

  7. Search volume growth (90 days)

    Growth → Product Opportunity Explorer → search the main keyword → choose your niche → copy the search volume growth %.

  8. Answer the comparison questions

    The ranks for offer, reviews and sales fill in automatically; check them against the questions, and add your gross margin and inventory (FBA + 3PL units).

  9. Repeat for every candidate

    The Total comparison tab collects them all.

Product page rating summary with 4.5 out of 5 highlighted.
This product goes in with a 4.5 rating.
Product Opportunity Explorer niche search with the search volume growth (past 90 days) column highlighted.

Choose the products

CriterionBetter is
Price / value for money (rank)Lower: the best offer against competitors
Reviews (rank)Lower: the most reviews against competitors
Sales you can grow toHigher: the biggest potential in the niche
RatingHigher = best, Normal = good, Lower = bad (avoid)
Search volume growthHigher
Gross profit margin %Higher
  • Mark the winner of each criterion in green (best offer, most reviews, highest margin…), then pick the 1–2 products with the best starting point.
  • Most important: the offer and the gross margin. Very high margin but a weak offer? Consider adjusting the price for a better offer while keeping a healthy 33–42%.
  • Being in the top 3 for reviews raises the chance of success a lot.
  • Big search volume growth signals strong potential; bigger growth potential = bigger upside.
  • Avoid products with a Lower rating: they're unlikely to succeed.

Want this done for you?

We run advertising, listings and account health for Amazon, Walmart and eBay brands. Start with a free review of your account.